A prime San Francisco commercial property’s value plunged from $300 million to just 20% of that price over three years. This kind of drop tells us something’s wrong with commercial real estate and interest rates. The problem goes beyond this one case. Commercial real estate valuations have taken a hit, dropping by over 20% throughout the market.
Many investors don’t fully grasp how interest rates shape property prices. The U.S. economy depends heavily on housing – it makes up 15-18% of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Rising interest rates hit commercial real estate hard, well beyond just making loans more expensive. Property owners face bigger monthly payments that can eat into their cash flow, especially in pricey markets. The construction industry has taken notice too. Office development has crashed by 83% while multifamily construction is down 70% because of these rate changes.
Let me show you the hard truths about interest rates and commercial real estate that banks prefer to keep quiet. We’ll get into how properties are being repriced, what supply shocks mean, and look at which properties are thriving or diving in today’s high-rate market.
Commercial real estate is a leveraged asset class because properties need large amounts of capital to purchase and operate. The difference between cap rates and borrowing costs is vital for investor returns.
Interest rates serve as the main driver of commercial real estate cycles. The Federal Reserve increased the federal funds rate by more than 525 basis points between March 2022 and July 2023. Recent reductions reached 100 basis points in the last quarter of 2024. This major change affects the entire CRE ecosystem.
Sales activity follows interest rate movements closely. Rate cuts boost transaction volumes while rate hikes reduce them. REIT prices typically need 13 months after the first cut to grow again. Property values take even longer at 20 months.
Property valuations change directly through capitalization rates. Rising interest rates push cap rates higher because investors need better returns to offset increased borrowing costs. This inverse relationship means:
Higher rates reduce what potential buyers can borrow. This shrinks the pool of bidders and makes properties take longer to sell. As a result, commercial real estate prices across the U.S. fell 8.0% in the first quarter of 2023 compared to the previous year.
The Federal Reserve has more control over short-term rates than long-term ones. Borrowers with shorter-term, floating-rate loans feel changes right away. Fixed-rate borrowers only face impacts when they refinance.
This creates a key difference: Fed actions mainly affect short-term loans tied to Prime or SOFR. Long-term fixed rates (5, 7, and 10-year mortgages) depend more on market forces like inflation expectations and economic forecasts.
The biggest challenge lies ahead. About $1.20 trillion of commercial mortgage loans will mature over 2025-2026. Average interest rates sit around 4.91% (2025) and 4.59% (2026) – much lower than current rates above 6.0%.
Fed rate hikes triggered a silent earthquake in commercial real estate markets. Lenders rarely discuss this with their clients. Behind closed doors, property valuations went through massive adjustments while public discussions centered on mortgage rates.
The commercial real estate market entered a “price discovery phase” following the Federal Reserve’s aggressive rate increases. Investors stopped transactions to reassess appropriate valuations in this new environment. CRE transaction volume dropped 22% year-over-year in Q1 2023, hitting the lowest levels since 2011 (excluding pandemic disruptions).
Property owners faced immediate pressure when they bought assets at peak valuations using short-term, floating-rate debt. Their debt service costs jumped overnight. Those who needed refinancing got a rude awakening – their property’s current value fell far below their outstanding loan balance.
The repricing happened despite stable or rising rental income across many commercial sectors. Many property owners refused to sell because their properties still generated consistent cash flow despite paper losses in valuation.
Capitalization rates mathematics explains this phenomenon. Investors just need higher returns on commercial properties when interest rates rise to maintain their spread above risk-free investments. The underlying asset value declines as the discount rate for future cash flows increases, even with similar or improved income streams.
Property owners face more than just refinancing challenges – they deal with opportunity costs. Investors cannot tap into potentially more lucrative opportunities that emerge in this changed landscape because their capital remains trapped in underperforming assets.
Property improvements and essential capital expenditures become harder to justify with declined asset values. This creates a cycle where delayed maintenance erodes property competitiveness further and ends up reducing tenant demand and rental rates.
Interest rates have created a second, more structural effect on commercial real estate – a dramatic construction slowdown that’s changing how supply works.
The numbers paint a clear picture: construction starts in office, industrial, multifamily, and retail sectors have dropped by about 75% compared to their five-year peaks. Office development has crashed by an incredible 83%, while multifamily construction is down by 70%.
Financing challenges caused this construction freeze. Higher interest rates have pushed up construction loan costs and reduced building values across commercial sectors. Many developers can’t find financing options that work with their project’s capital stack.
The financing situation is getting tougher as $2.75 trillion in commercial mortgage loans will come due between 2023-2027, with $544 billion due through 2025 alone.
Property owners face a perfect storm: they must deal with higher monthly payments, smaller loan-to-value ratios, and less cash flow. Traditional lenders have become pickier, but alternative debt sources have stepped in. These sources now make up 24% of US commercial real estate lending volume last year. Right now, about $585 billion in commercial real estate “dry powder” is ready to deploy.
This limited supply, combined with the ongoing housing affordability crisis, creates an unexpected benefit for existing property owners. Less new construction and steady demand mean asset owners might get more control over pricing as time goes on.
Higher mortgage rates force many potential homebuyers to keep renting. This helps keep occupancy rates high in multifamily properties. Commercial landlords dealing with refinancing challenges might offset their higher borrowing costs by raising rents over time.
Higher interest rates don’t affect all commercial properties the same way. The commercial real estate market has split dramatically, creating clear winners and losers in today’s high-rate environment.
Class A properties have shown remarkable strength against financing challenges. These premium assets still attract quality tenants who will pay premium rates. Luxury multifamily properties face some market pressure but maintain their strong position. The affordable multifamily sector continues to grow as homebuyers find themselves priced out of single-family markets.
The industrial property sector benefits from ongoing growth in domestic manufacturing and infrastructure spending. Property owners with strong balance sheets can now expand their portfolios at better prices.
Class B and especially C properties face serious survival challenges. A telling example comes from San Francisco, where an office tower originally worth $300 million before COVID-19 sold for just 20% of that price after losing its main tenant. This massive drop in value isn’t unique – older Class B office buildings struggle everywhere with low demand, empty spaces, and longer waiting times to find tenants.
Class C properties can barely get financing now. Lenders want higher vacancy reserves and charge much more interest. These buildings face mounting pressure from both daily operations and money problems.
Smart investors have adapted to this split market through several methods:
Cash buyers now have a big advantage. They can buy at good prices and refinance later when rates come down. Still, success in this market depends on careful analysis and testing different scenarios.
Rising interest rates have revolutionized the commercial real estate world. These changes go way beyond the reach and influence of basic financing costs. They have altered the map of property values, construction work, and investment plans throughout the market. Interest rates are the foundations of real estate cycles, though mainstream financial institutions rarely admit this fact.
The market now tells two different stories. Class A properties show remarkable strength despite tough financing conditions. Meanwhile, many Class B and C assets struggle to survive. This split creates problems and opens doors for smart investors ready to change their methods.
The upcoming $1.20 trillion wave of commercial mortgage refinancing will without doubt show which investors came prepared. Property owners must face this new reality and plan their next steps. Investors with cash are ready to buy troubled assets. Those with loans coming due should expect very different terms than their original deals.
The current pause in construction could help existing property owners later. Supply shortages might lead to higher rental rates. This could help offset increased debt costs for owners who successfully guide themselves through refinancing.
Of course, commercial real estate remains a solid investment option. Success now just needs more expertise, stronger finances, and smarter strategies than in the past low-rate era. Smart investors who grasp how interest rates affect property performance will spot opportunities where others see roadblocks. The reality of interest rates and commercial real estate might seem tough, but accepting it is the first step to success in this market.
The Essential Guide to Research and Development Tax Credit: State vs Federal Benefits Did you…
How to Identify Qualified Research Expenses: A Plain-English Guide [With Examples] The R&D tax credit…
Research and Development Tax Credit: Simple Guide to the 4-Part Test R&D tax credits provide…
Research and Development Tax Credit Guide: From Qualification to Claims [Expert Tips] R&D tax credits…
Real Estate Tax Deductions: A Property Pro's Guide to Maximum Savings Tax deductions for real…
The Real Estate Pro's Guide to Guaranteed Cash Flow Forecasting Cashflow real estate forecasting serves…
This website uses cookies.